Bar Madonna logo

Bar Madonna

367 Metropolitan Ave, Brooklyn, New York, USA
ClosedOpens at 17:00
Check-ins
0
Likes
0
Award
1

About

Expect Italian American drinks with a serious amaro backbone, plus a short list of familiar classics done cleanly. The space feels polished but not precious, with a little artful edge that keeps it from turning formal. Come hungry: the food goes well beyond bar snacks, so it works just as well for a full meal as it does for a round at the bar.

Awards and rankings

North America's 50 Best Bars
No. 36 in 2026
North America

Menu

This list does not claim to be up to date, complete or correct. The drinks and prices on the bar’s own menu are authoritative.

Jan 14, 2026
Beet Bussdown$18.00

Ilegal Mezcal, Pasilla, Golden Beet, White Balsamic, Pineapple

Jan 14, 2026
Campari & Chamomile$17.00

Campari, Comoz, Honey, Chamomile Soda

Jan 14, 2026
Coffee & Cigarette$18.00

Bacardi 8, Mr. Black, Blood Orange, Coconut, Mole

Jan 14, 2026
Don Fanucci$19.00

Michter’s Bourbon, Cognac, Faccia Alpino, Olive Oil, Thyme, Apricot

Jan 14, 2026
Gemma’s Sauce$18.00

Condesa Gin, Salers, Cocchi Americano, Strawberry, Coconut

Jan 14, 2026
Grapes on Grapes$18.00

Espolon Tequila, St-Germain, Grapes, Aloe, Soda

Jan 14, 2026
Limoncello Milk Punch$18.00

Limoncello, Fords Gin, Mijenta Tequila, Genmaicha, Shiso, Clarified Milk

Jan 14, 2026
Marinos Highball$15.00

Grey Goose, Alma Finca, Yuzushu, Cherry, Soda

Jan 14, 2026
Mela Tini$19.00

Grey Goose, Calvados, Pomme Verte, Green Apple Juice, Fennel

Jan 14, 2026

Been to Bar Madonna?

Check in, rate what you drank and keep it in your bar diary.

Get the app

More bars in New York

All 112 bars in New York